Its not the person you are voting for it is the season and i think 2003 because you didnt know who was going to win and it had so many talented people on it.

Guy Sebastin the best........pfffft! When did he tour last, when did he release an album last or a single the outright winner of 2003 was Shannon Noll, the reason and the only reason Guy won was because of all the stupid teeny boppers who voted for the guy with the Fro.
Shannon Noll has eclipsed Guy Sebastin in singles, albums and tours, idol management should ban children from the vote, they wouldn't know real talent if it bit them on the ass

Guy Sebastian is the first Australian Idol and the best Australian Idol. He set standards that no recent Australian Idol have met. Guy is simply the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

i think wes is the best by far and i wanted to vote for him but my mum said i couldnt and i am also going to get his new single for chtistmas and i want to hopefully get every cd he makes luke wasnt too bad but i didnt really like him that much wes is totally the best

Casey Donovan is simply the best..besides her personnal issues..she was simply stunning vocally. Her debut album is bloody awesome...worth buying and having a good listen too.

wes carr is the BEST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
he really deserved to win.
i didnt like luke.
his voice was weird and hi beard was horrible i wanted to shave it off every time i saw it.
wes is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

NATALIE GAUCI IS THE BEST!!!!!!!

So sad that her album isnt going to be out soon.....